Does Georgia bad-faith law cover claims against the other driver’s insurer?

· 3 min read

The bad-faith penalty in O.C.G.A. § 33-4-6 is built around the relationship between an insurer and its own policyholder, so an injured person who is not insured by the at-fault driver’s carrier cannot use that statute against the other side’s insurer. Georgia does, however, give a third-party claimant one narrow statutory bad-faith remedy against the at-fault driver’s insurer: O.C.G.A. § 33-4-7, which is confined to motor-vehicle property-damage claims and does not reach bodily-injury claims.

Why the statute is first-party

Section 33-4-6 penalizes an insurer that refuses, without reasonable justification, to pay a covered loss owed to its own insured. The duty runs from the insurer to the person it insures. An injured claimant pursuing the at-fault driver’s liability coverage is a third party to that policy, not a party to the insurance contract. As a result, the third party usually lacks the direct first-party relationship the statute requires, and § 33-4-6 is not the vehicle for that claimant to penalize the other driver’s insurer.

This is a frequent source of confusion, because both situations involve “an insurance company behaving badly.” The legal distinction is who the insurer owes a contractual duty to pay.

Which statutes reach which insurer

The cleanest way to keep these straight is by the contractual relationship each rule protects:

  • The injured person’s own insurer. A first-party dispute, such as a delay in paying uninsured-motorist or medical-payments coverage, is where § 33-4-6 actually operates, because the claimant is the policyholder the statute protects.
  • The at-fault driver’s insurer. A third party with a vehicle or property loss can invoke § 33-4-7, which imposes an affirmative duty on the liability insurer to investigate, evaluate, and settle a property-damage claim in good faith once liability is reasonably clear. A breach exposes the insurer to a penalty of the greater of 50 percent of the insured’s liability or $5,000.00 plus attorney’s fees, but the claimant must first send a statutory demand and allow 60 days to settle. Because § 33-4-7 stops at property damage, a third party’s bodily-injury claim has no parallel statute; the only leverage there comes from the separate duty a liability insurer owes its own insured to settle reasonably, a duty that protects the at-fault driver rather than the injured claimant.

The takeaway is a matter of categories: § 33-4-6 is keyed to the claimant’s own policy, § 33-4-7 reaches the other driver’s insurer only for property damage, and a third party’s injury claim depends on a separate, insured-protective settlement duty rather than any direct statutory bad-faith right.

The bottom line

Georgia’s § 33-4-6 bad-faith penalty is a first-party remedy and does not let an injured claimant punish the at-fault driver’s insurer, because the claimant is not that insurer’s policyholder. The one statute aimed at the other carrier, § 33-4-7, covers a third party’s property-damage loss but not a bodily-injury claim. For injuries, then, the claimant has no direct statutory bad-faith right against the at-fault carrier and must rely on that insurer’s separate duty to its own insured to settle within policy limits.

This article is for general educational and informational purposes only and is not legal advice. It does not create an attorney-client relationship, and Georgia law may change. For advice about a specific situation, consult a licensed Georgia personal injury attorney.

Related:

  1. How much is the bad-faith penalty against a Georgia insurer worth? When a Georgia insurer is found to have refused a first-party claim in bad faith, the statutory penalty is calculated as a percentage of the loss, with a fixed floor.......
  2. Does the bad-faith penalty apply to my own UM insurer in Georgia? A claim against an injured person's own uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM) carrier is a first-party claim, and Georgia attaches a bad-faith penalty to it. The controlling provision is not the general......
  3. Can the at-fault driver assign me their bad-faith claim against their own insurer? In Georgia, the duty an insurer owes to handle settlement reasonably runs to its own policyholder, not to the injured claimant. So when an insurer's failure to settle leaves the......
  4. What is insurer bad faith under O.C.G.A. 33-4-6 in Georgia? Insurer bad faith under Georgia's first-party statute refers to an insurance company's unjustified refusal to pay a valid claim under its own policyholder's coverage. O.C.G.A. § 33-4-6 creates a penalty......
  5. What 60-day demand must I send before suing my Georgia insurer for bad faith? Before a first-party bad-faith claim against a Georgia insurer can proceed, the policyholder must make a demand and give the insurer 60 days to pay the covered loss. O.C.G.A. §......
  6. Can I recover attorney fees when my Georgia insurer acts in bad faith? Yes. Georgia's first-party bad-faith statute allows a policyholder to recover reasonable attorney fees, in addition to the covered loss and the bad-faith penalty, when an insurer's refusal to pay is......
  7. Do I file my claim against the driver’s insurer or Uber’s insurer first? Which insurer comes first depends on who caused the crash and on the Uber driver's app phase, because those two facts decide which policy is primary. There is no single......
  8. What counts as a reasonable justification that defeats a Georgia bad-faith claim? A Georgia bad-faith claim under O.C.G.A. § 33-4-6 fails if the insurer had a reasonable basis for refusing to pay. The entire concept of bad faith turns on the absence......
  9. How do I bring my own UM insurer into a Georgia lawsuit against an unknown driver? When a hit-and-run or phantom driver causes a crash and cannot be identified, Georgia's uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM) system still gives the injured person a path to recover, but it runs......
  10. What is health-insurer subrogation against my Georgia injury settlement? When a health plan pays the medical bills from an accident that someone else caused, it usually claims a right to be paid back out of any money the injured......
  11. How does an insurer decide if my car is a total loss in Georgia? An insurer treats a vehicle as a total loss when fixing it no longer makes economic sense, judged against the car's value rather than the owner's attachment to it. The......
  12. What does a reservation-of-rights letter from my Georgia insurer mean? A reservation-of-rights letter is an insurer's written notice that it will look into a claim and may provide a defense, while preserving the option to deny coverage later if it......
  13. What is a policy-limits demand and why does it pressure a Georgia insurer? A policy-limits demand is an offer to fully settle an injury claim in exchange for the at-fault driver's available coverage, usually within a stated deadline. It pressures a Georgia liability......
  14. How does Georgia’s made-whole doctrine limit my health insurer’s reimbursement? Under Georgia law, a health insurer generally cannot collect reimbursement from an injury recovery until the injured person has first been fully compensated for the entire loss. Georgia codifies this......
  15. What does Georgia’s share-the-road duty require drivers to do around cyclists? Georgia law puts concrete obligations on drivers around cyclists, the most specific being a minimum passing distance. The duty to share the road is not just a slogan on a......

Leave a Reply